GPT-5.6 Sol (Codex) on Answer contract questions

Passed in 20s. Attempt 1. Run 20260904T114318Z-gpt-5-6-sol-contract-questions-1.

Task

Answer five contract questions

Read agreement.md and questions.md.

Write answers.json with one object for each question id. Each answer must be concise, answer the question in plain words, and cite the exact numbered clause where the answer appears:

{
  "q1": {"answer": "...", "clause": "7.2"}
}

Include all five ids, q1 through q5. Use only the agreement, not outside assumptions.

Command

codex exec --skip-git-repo-check --dangerously-bypass-approvals-and-sandbox -m gpt-5.6-sol -c model_reasoning_effort=high --output-last-message /tmp/atris-bench/20260904T114318Z-gpt-5-6-sol-contract-questions-1/last-message.txt 'You are working in the current folder. Do the task in TASK.md and write the outputs to the exact paths it names.
Do not ask questions. When done, stop.

# Answer five contract questions

Read `agreement.md` and `questions.md`.

Write `answers.json` with one object for each question id. Each answer must be concise, answer the
question in plain words, and cite the exact numbered clause where the answer appears:

` ` `json
{
  "q1": {"answer": "...", "clause": "7.2"}
}
` ` `

Include all five ids, `q1` through `q5`. Use only the agreement, not outside assumptions.'

Output

Completed [answers.json](/private/tmp/atris-bench/20260904T114318Z-gpt-5-6-sol-contract-questions-1/work/answers.json).


[stderr]
Reading additional input from stdin...
OpenAI Codex v0.153.0
--------
workdir: /private/tmp/atris-bench/20260904T114318Z-gpt-5-6-sol-contract-questions-1/work
model: gpt-5.6-sol
provider: openai
approval: never
sandbox: danger-full-access
reasoning effort: high
reasoning summaries: none
session id: 01a06c3a-f77d-7801-a65b-260392821b3d
--------
user
You are working in the current folder. Do the task in TASK.md and write the outputs to the exact paths it names.
Do not ask questions. When done, stop.

# Answer five contract questions

Read `agreement.md` and `questions.md`.

Write `answers.json` with one object for each question id. Each answer must be concise, answer the
question in plain words, and cite the exact numbered clause where the answer appears:

` ` `json
{
  "q1": {"answer": "...", "clause": "7.2"}
}
` ` `

Include all five ids, `q1` through `q5`. Use only the agreement, not outside assumptions.
codex
I’m using the keshav-comms skill for the concise handoff style, then I’ll read the task and agreement and produce the exact JSON requested.
exec
/bin/zsh -lc "sed -n '1,240p' /Users/keshavrao/.codex/skills/keshav-comms/SKILL.md && sed -n '1,220p' TASK.md && sed -n '1,320p' agreement.md && sed -n '1,220p' questions.md" in /private/tmp/atris-bench/20260904T114318Z-gpt-5-6-sol-contract-questions-1/work
 succeeded in 0ms:
---
name: keshav-comms
description: Keshav's default reply style for speed-reading in a small terminal pane — one idea per beat, hard line cap, no scroll. Use on every conversational reply unless the user asks for depth. Triggers on every chat, brainstorm, status, and handoff.
---

# keshav-comms

House style for Keshav. Goal: **never scroll** in Ghostty/split panes.

## Hard limits

- **Stream (default):** max **4 lines** total (blank lines count).
- **Batch / handoff:** max **6 lines** total.
- **One idea per beat.** Prefer **1 line** when possible.
- **Blank line between beats** when using 2+ lines.
- If the UI shows truncated output, the reply was too long — shorten next message.

## Format

- Plain English. PM-smart, not jargon-first.
- **No** headers, bullets, numbered lists, tables, or preamble.
- **No** agreement reflex ("great question", "you're right").
- Start with the answer.
- **Recommend one path** — do not enumerate options unless asked.
- Code blocks, diffs, and file paths stay literal when needed.

## Phases

| Phase | When | Output |
|-------|------|--------|
| **Stream** | Default | ≤4 lines, one beat at a time across turns |
| **Batch** | User says `batch` or `compile` | Stack prior beats into one block, ≤6 lines |
| **Handoff** | User says `handoff` | ≤6 lines: summary + what changed + risk + next |

## Signal words

- `go` — execute work; progress replies stay in stream mode.
- `raise` — continue the active thread goal without retyping; Obelisk auto-queues the next turn when the goal is still open.
- `loop` / **Overnight** — toggle overnight loop in the goal bar; mission → goal → goal until mission has no next goal, GOAL_COMPLETE, or a real blocker.
- `batch` — compile conversation so far.
- `handoff` — compile for another human or agent.

## Example (stream)

User: is the hook firing on boot a problem?

Yes — noise, not failure.

It expects a forgepilot log that was never written today.

Want disable hook or write the log?

## When NOT to use

- User explicitly asks for a long writeup, doc, or deep dive.
- Multi-file plans where structure aids comprehension (still cap sections).
# Answer five contract questions

Read `agreement.md` and `questions.md`.

Write `answers.json` with one object for each question id. Each answer must be concise, answer the
question in plain words, and cite the exact numbered clause where the answer appears:

` ` `json
{
  "q1": {"answer": "...", "clause": "7.2"}
}
` ` `

Include all five ids, `q1` through `q5`. Use only the agreement, not outside assumptions.
# Business Services Agreement

This Business Services Agreement is entered as of September 1, 2026, by and between Harbor Field
Systems, Inc. ("Provider") and Juniper Works LLC ("Customer"). The parties agree as follows.

## 1. Services

### 1.1 Scope

Provider will supply the hosted workflow, reporting, and support services described in each order
form signed by both parties. An order form may set quantities, service dates, and implementation
milestones, but it does not change this Agreement unless it identifies the clause being changed.

### 1.2 Access

Customer may permit its employees and contractors to use the service for Customer's internal
business. Customer is responsible for account credentials, authorized users, and activity under
its accounts. Customer will promptly notify Provider of suspected unauthorized access.

### 1.3 Changes

The parties may add work through a written change order. Provider is not required to begin changed
work before both parties approve its scope, timing, and fees. Routine product improvements that do
not materially reduce purchased functionality do not require a change order.

## 2. Implementation and Support

### 2.1 Cooperation

Customer will provide timely access to personnel, systems, and accurate data reasonably needed for
implementation. A delay caused by missing Customer input moves the affected milestone by the same
number of business days unless the parties agree otherwise in writing.

### 2.2 Support

Provider will offer email support from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time on business days,
excluding federal holidays. Provider will acknowledge a severity-one production incident within
two business hours and will provide reasonable progress updates until service is restored.

### 2.3 Acceptance

A deliverable is accepted when Customer confirms acceptance in writing or uses it in production.
If Customer gives Provider a specific written description of a material nonconformity within ten
business days after delivery, Provider will use reasonable efforts to correct it and resubmit it.

## 3. Term

### 3.1 Initial Term

The initial term begins on the effective date and continues for twelve months, unless it ends
earlier under Section 7. An order form may have a shorter service period, but that does not shorten
the term of this Agreement for other active order forms.

### 3.2 Automatic Renewal

After the initial term, this Agreement automatically renews for successive 12-month terms unless
either party gives a valid nonrenewal notice at least 45 days before the current term ends. A
nonrenewal under this clause takes effect at the end of the current term and is not a termination
for convenience under Section 7.2.

### 3.3 Order Forms at Expiration

Expiration of this Agreement ends any order form that has not already expired, unless the parties
sign a written transition plan. Accrued payment obligations and clauses that by their nature should
survive remain effective after expiration.

## 4. Customer Data

### 4.1 Ownership

Customer retains all right, title, and interest in data it submits to the service. Customer grants
Provider a limited right to host, copy, process, and transmit that data only as needed to provide,
secure, and support the service and to meet legal obligations.

### 4.2 Security

Provider will maintain reasonable administrative, technical, and physical safeguards appropriate
to the nature of Customer data. Provider will notify Customer without undue delay after confirming
a security incident that compromises Customer data in Provider's control.

### 4.3 Return and Deletion

For thirty days after service ends, Customer may export its data using the service's standard
export tools. Provider may then delete Customer data from active systems, except for copies kept in
routine backups or as required by law. Backup copies remain protected under this Agreement.

## 5. Fees and Payment

### 5.1 Fees

Customer will pay the fees stated in each order form. Except where an order form expressly says a
fee is refundable, fees are noncancelable and nonrefundable. Quantities committed for a billing
period may not be reduced during that billing period.

### 5.2 Invoices

Provider will invoice subscription fees in advance and approved usage or expenses in arrears.
Customer will pay each undisputed invoice within 30 days after the invoice date by electronic funds
transfer or another method stated on the invoice.

### 5.3 Disputes

Customer must give written notice of a good-faith invoice dispute before the payment due date and
must pay the undisputed portion on time. The notice must identify the invoice, disputed amount, and
reason. The parties will work promptly and in good faith to resolve the dispute.

### 5.4 Late Payments

An undisputed amount not paid when due accrues interest from the due date at 1.5% per month or the
maximum lawful rate, whichever is lower. Customer will also reimburse reasonable collection costs
awarded by a court. Provider may not charge interest on a timely disputed amount while the parties
are resolving that dispute in good faith.

## 6. Confidentiality

### 6.1 Confidential Information

Confidential Information means nonpublic information disclosed by one party that is marked
confidential or that a reasonable person would understand to be confidential. It includes product
plans, security information, customer lists, pricing, business methods, and Customer data.

### 6.2 Duties

The receiving party will use Confidential Information only to perform or receive services under
this Agreement. It will protect that information with at least reasonable care and disclose it only
to personnel and advisers who need it and are bound by suitable confidentiality duties.

### 6.3 Exclusions and Required Disclosure

Confidential Information does not include information independently developed without use of the
other party's information, rightfully received without restriction, or publicly available through
no breach. A legally compelled recipient may disclose only what is required after giving advance
notice when the law permits.

## 7. Termination

### 7.1 Termination for Cause

Either party may terminate this Agreement or an affected order form if the other party materially
breaches it and does not cure the breach within 30 days after written notice. If the breach cannot
reasonably be cured, or involves unlawful use of the service, termination may be immediate upon
written notice.

### 7.2 Termination for Convenience

Either party may terminate this Agreement for convenience by giving the other party at least 30
days' advance written notice. Customer remains responsible for fees committed through the
effective termination date. This right does not create a refund of prepaid fees unless an order
form expressly provides one.

### 7.3 Effect of Termination

When an order ends, Customer's right to use the related service ends. Each party will return or
destroy the other's Confidential Information on request, subject to Section 4.3 and legal retention
duties. Sections concerning accrued payment, confidentiality, disclaimers, liability, and general
terms survive.

## 8. Warranties

### 8.1 Mutual Authority

Each party represents that it has authority to enter this Agreement and that doing so does not
violate another binding obligation. Provider warrants that it will perform professional services
in a professional and workmanlike manner using personnel with appropriate skill.

### 8.2 Service Warranty

Provider warrants that the hosted service will materially conform to its documentation during the
term. Customer's exclusive remedy for a verified breach is re-performance or correction; if
Provider cannot correct the breach within a reasonable period, Customer may terminate the affected
order and receive a prorated refund of prepaid fees for the unused period.

### 8.3 Disclaimer

Except for the express warranties in this Agreement, each party disclaims all implied warranties
to the extent allowed by law, including warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular
purpose, and noninfringement. Provider does not warrant that every interruption can be prevented.

## 9. Indemnification

### 9.1 Provider Indemnity

Provider will defend Customer against a third-party claim that the unmodified service infringes a
United States patent, copyright, or trademark and will pay damages finally awarded or included in
an approved settlement. Provider may modify or replace the affected service or terminate it with a
prorated refund if continued use is likely to be enjoined.

### 9.2 Customer Indemnity

Customer will defend Provider against a third-party claim arising from Customer data or Customer's
unlawful use of the service and will pay damages finally awarded or included in an approved
settlement. This duty does not cover a claim caused by Provider's unauthorized modification.

### 9.3 Process

The protected party must promptly notify the defending party and provide reasonable cooperation.
The defending party controls the defense and settlement, but it may not admit fault for or impose
a nonmonetary duty on the protected party without that party's prior written consent.

## 10. Limitation of Liability

### 10.1 Excluded Damages

To the maximum extent permitted by law, neither party is liable for indirect, incidental, special,
exemplary, punitive, or consequential damages, or for lost profits, revenues, goodwill, or data,
arising from this Agreement, even if advised that such damages were possible.

### 10.2 Exceptions

The exclusions and cap do not apply to Customer's payment obligations, either party's fraud or
willful misconduct, a breach of confidentiality, or indemnification obligations. Nothing limits a
liability that governing law does not permit the parties to limit.

### 10.3 General Cap

Except for the matters listed in Section 10.2, each party's total aggregate liability arising out
of or related to this Agreement will not exceed the fees paid or payable by Customer under this
Agreement in the 12 months immediately before the event giving rise to the first claim.

## 11. Publicity and Records

### 11.1 Publicity

Neither party may issue a press release naming the other without prior written consent. Provider
may list Customer's name and logo in a factual customer list only after Customer approves the form
of use. Either party may revoke that approval for future use by written notice.

### 11.2 Records

Each party will maintain records reasonably sufficient to support its invoices and compliance
obligations for at least three years. Any agreed audit must occur during ordinary business hours,
on reasonable notice, and in a manner that avoids unnecessary disruption or disclosure.

## 12. General Terms

### 12.1 Notices

A notice under this Agreement must be in writing and delivered by personal delivery, nationally
recognized overnight courier, or email followed by confirmation to the addresses on the applicable
order form. A notice is effective on confirmed receipt, not merely when sent.

### 12.2 Assignment

Neither party may assign this Agreement without the other's written consent, except to an affiliate
or in connection with a merger, reorganization, or sale of substantially all relevant assets. An
assignment does not relieve the assigning party of obligations accrued before the assignment.

### 12.3 Force Majeure

Neither party is liable for delay caused by circumstances beyond its reasonable control, excluding
payment obligations. The affected party will promptly notify the other, use reasonable efforts to
reduce the delay, and resume performance as soon as practical.

### 12.4 Governing Law

This Agreement is governed by the laws of the State of Delaware, without regard to conflict-of-law
rules. The state and federal courts located in Wilmington, Delaware have exclusive jurisdiction,
and each party consents to venue in those courts.

### 12.5 Entire Agreement

This Agreement and its order forms are the complete agreement about their subject and replace all
prior or contemporaneous proposals and discussions. A waiver or amendment must be in a writing
signed by authorized representatives of both parties. Electronic signatures and counterparts are
effective as originals.
# Questions

1. `q1`: How much advance notice is required to terminate for convenience?
2. `q2`: What is the general liability cap?
3. `q3`: Which state's law governs the agreement?
4. `q4`: How long is each automatic renewal term?
5. `q5`: What interest applies to a late payment?

apply patch
patch: completed
/private/tmp/atris-bench/20260904T114318Z-gpt-5-6-sol-contract-questions-1/work/answers.json
diff --git a/answers.json b/answers.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..deba082ffd2782b8846d2ffb9121df12ba366c08
--- /dev/null
+++ b/answers.json
@@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
+{
+  "q1": {
+    "answer": "At least 30 days' advance written notice is required.",
+    "clause": "7.2"
+  },
+  "q2": {
+    "answer": "Except for the matters in clause 10.2, each party's total aggregate liability is capped at the fees paid or payable by the Customer under the agreement in the 12 months immediately before the event giving rise to the first claim.",
+    "clause": "10.3"
+  },
+  "q3": {
+    "answer": "Delaware law governs the agreement.",
+    "clause": "12.4"
+  },
+  "q4": {
+    "answer": "Each automatic renewal term is 12 months.",
+    "clause": "3.2"
+  },
+  "q5": {
+    "answer": "An undisputed late payment accrues interest at 1.5% per month or the maximum lawful rate, whichever is lower.",
+    "clause": "5.4"
+  }
+}

exec
/bin/zsh -lc "jq -e 'keys == [\"q1\",\"q2\",\"q3\",\"q4\",\"q5\"] and all(.[]; (keys | sort) == [\"answer\",\"clause\"])' answers.json" in /private/tmp/atris-bench/20260904T114318Z-gpt-5-6-sol-contract-questions-1/work
 succeeded in 0ms:
true

diff --git a/answers.json b/answers.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..deba082ffd2782b8846d2ffb9121df12ba366c08
--- /dev/null
+++ b/answers.json
@@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
+{
+  "q1": {
+    "answer": "At least 30 days' advance written notice is required.",
+    "clause": "7.2"
+  },
+  "q2": {
+    "answer": "Except for the matters in clause 10.2, each party's total aggregate liability is capped at the fees paid or payable by the Customer under the agreement in the 12 months immediately before the event giving rise to the first claim.",
+    "clause": "10.3"
+  },
+  "q3": {
+    "answer": "Delaware law governs the agreement.",
+    "clause": "12.4"
+  },
+  "q4": {
+    "answer": "Each automatic renewal term is 12 months.",
+    "clause": "3.2"
+  },
+  "q5": {
+    "answer": "An undisputed late payment accrues interest at 1.5% per month or the maximum lawful rate, whichever is lower.",
+    "clause": "5.4"
+  }
+}

codex
Completed [answers.json](/private/tmp/atris-bench/20260904T114318Z-gpt-5-6-sol-contract-questions-1/work/answers.json).
diff --git a/answers.json b/answers.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..deba082ffd2782b8846d2ffb9121df12ba366c08
--- /dev/null
+++ b/answers.json
@@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
+{
+  "q1": {
+    "answer": "At least 30 days' advance written notice is required.",
+    "clause": "7.2"
+  },
+  "q2": {
+    "answer": "Except for the matters in clause 10.2, each party's total aggregate liability is capped at the fees paid or payable by the Customer under the agreement in the 12 months immediately before the event giving rise to the first claim.",
+    "clause": "10.3"
+  },
+  "q3": {
+    "answer": "Delaware law governs the agreement.",
+    "clause": "12.4"
+  },
+  "q4": {
+    "answer": "Each automatic renewal term is 12 months.",
+    "clause": "3.2"
+  },
+  "q5": {
+    "answer": "An undisputed late payment accrues interest at 1.5% per month or the maximum lawful rate, whichever is lower.",
+    "clause": "5.4"
+  }
+}

tokens used
13,533


[final message]
Completed [answers.json](/private/tmp/atris-bench/20260904T114318Z-gpt-5-6-sol-contract-questions-1/work/answers.json).

Files produced

answers.json

{
  "q1": {
    "answer": "At least 30 days' advance written notice is required.",
    "clause": "7.2"
  },
  "q2": {
    "answer": "Except for the matters in clause 10.2, each party's total aggregate liability is capped at the fees paid or payable by the Customer under the agreement in the 12 months immediately before the event giving rise to the first claim.",
    "clause": "10.3"
  },
  "q3": {
    "answer": "Delaware law governs the agreement.",
    "clause": "12.4"
  },
  "q4": {
    "answer": "Each automatic renewal term is 12 months.",
    "clause": "3.2"
  },
  "q5": {
    "answer": "An undisputed late payment accrues interest at 1.5% per month or the maximum lawful rate, whichever is lower.",
    "clause": "5.4"
  }
}

Checker

{"passed": true, "score": 1.0, "notes": "5/5 answers have the exact clause and key term"}

Judge

Not used for this task.